Work at Category Leaders

Being a mid-level IC at a category winner beats being a senior leader at a tier-two player

Gokul Rajaram
Picking where to work, hiring, investing, and product development

Work at Category Leaders

"I would much rather be the number two or number three person, if you think of it that way, in the leader in a space, than the top person. Say Google versus Yahoo. I saw even if you're the VP of product at Yahoo or the head of product at Yahoo versus a ICPM at Google, you probably want to be the ICPM at Google. I bet you all day long." - Gokul Rajaram

What It Is

Work at Category Leaders is a counterintuitive career principle: take a lower-level role at the market leader rather than a higher-title role at a second-tier company. The benefits of association with a winner - talent network, brand halo, operational learning - compound far more than a title bump at a company that's fighting from behind.

Gokul demonstrated this in practice by convincing someone to take a step down in title to join Coinbase (category leader in crypto) rather than take a senior role at a tier-two e-commerce company. That person still thanks him.

How It Works

Why Category Leaders Win

Quality of Talent:

  • Winners attract A-players who want to be around other A-players
  • You learn from the best in every function
  • Your network compounds with high-quality connections

Brand Halo:

  • "You worked at [winner]? You must be good"
  • Unfair but real attribution of company success to individuals
  • Opens doors for future opportunities

Operational Excellence:

  • See how things work at scale
  • Learn systems and processes that work
  • Understand what "good" looks like

Network Effects:

  • Alumni networks of winners are more valuable
  • Peers become founders, executives, investors
  • References carry more weight

The Tradeoff Is Worth It

Even significant title drops are worth it:

Tier-Two Option Category Leader Option Take This One
VP of Product Senior PM Senior PM at Leader
Head of Engineering Engineering Manager EM at Leader
Chief Marketing Officer Marketing Director Director at Leader

Long-Term vs Short-Term

Short-term: You might have more scope and authority at the smaller player

Long-term: The category leader gives you:

  • Better stories for future opportunities
  • Stronger reference network
  • Deeper operational knowledge
  • More respected brand on resume

How to Apply It

  1. Identify the category leaders - Not just well-known companies, but actual winners in their spaces

  2. Look beyond competitors - Consider adjacent spaces where clear leaders exist

  3. Consider trajectory - An emerging leader today may be the dominant one in 5 years

  4. Weight brand appropriately - The halo effect is real and lasts for years

  5. Don't over-index on title - Scope, learning, and company quality matter more

  6. Think about who you'll work with - The people are the most durable asset

When to Apply It

  • Comparing offers between companies at different market positions
  • Deciding whether to stay at a struggling company vs. move
  • Evaluating step-down opportunities at stronger companies
  • Early-mid career when building skills and reputation

When Title Matters More

Title may be more important when:

  • You need a specific title for external credibility (e.g., VP for certain sales conversations)
  • You're late career and title reflects earned authority
  • The category leader has serious cultural or ethical problems
  • The "smaller" company is actually a future category leader

Source

  • Guest: Gokul Rajaram
  • Episode: "Picking where to work, hiring, investing, and product development"
  • Key Discussion: (00:10:35) - Benefits of working at category leaders
  • YouTube: Watch on YouTube

Related Frameworks

Back to Career